Emerging Regional Powers and the Reshaping of Global Order

 The global political order is undergoing a profound transformation. Historically dominated by Western powers—especially the United States—the contemporary international system is increasingly defined by shifting alliances, competing strategic interests, and multipolar dynamics. A crucial theater of this transformation is the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), now a pivotal area for power projection, maritime security, and geopolitical competition. The main actors in this evolving order include the United States, Russia, and China, whose policies in the region are increasingly shaping the course of future global stability.

The United States: Architect of Global Norms, Exempt from Accountability

The United States has long positioned itself as a champion of global governance, setting the framework for institutions like the International Criminal Court (ICC). However, this stance is marred by selective adherence to international laws, particularly when the U.S. itself is exempt from their jurisdiction. This discrepancy highlights a broader issue within the liberal world order: the most powerful states often remain above the very systems they advocate for, leading to an asymmetric approach to global governance. While the U.S. champions democracy and human rights, the selective enforcement of these values undermines the credibility of international systems.

Russia: Strategic Non-Alignment and the Politics of Silence

Russia's approach, by contrast, centers on multipolarity, opposing the idea of a unipolar, U.S.-dominated world. In global affairs, Russia tends to leverage strategic silence, positioning itself flexibly to avoid entanglement in power struggles while asserting influence through partnerships and regional balancing. In South Asia and the Indian Ocean, where India plays a central geopolitical role, Russia has adopted a neutral stance on issues like the Eelam Tamil conflict, recognizing India's sphere of influence and maintaining its own interests in the region. This "silence" is not a withdrawal but a deliberate strategy of restraint, aiming to avoid antagonizing India while preserving regional influence.

China: Rising Power, Religious Persecution, and Maritime Expansion

China’s rise has been one of the most defining global shifts in the 21st century. While China’s economic expansion through initiatives like the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has granted it considerable influence, its geopolitical ambitions are tempered by significant internal challenges. A central issue is China's treatment of its minority populations. Despite making up only about 2% of the population, the Uighur Muslim community has faced severe persecution, with reports of mass detentions in Xinjiang and the suppression of religious freedoms. The Chinese government's crackdown on churches and Christian communities adds another layer to these violations. Religious freedom remains heavily restricted, and the recent targeting of religious communities shows a stark contrast with the multi-cultural models embraced by many Western nations.

In contrast to the West, which has largely embraced multiculturalism as a foundational aspect of its democratic societies, China's state-driven cultural homogeneity seeks to erase diversity in favor of a unified national identity. China's forced assimilation policies, including restrictions on language, religion, and culture, not only stifle diversity but also suppress the individual freedoms of its citizens. This heavy-handed approach to governance has led to mounting tensions within the country's borders, and the potential for conflict with its neighbors is high due to territorial ambitions in the South China Sea and beyond.

The West: Capitalism and Multiculturalism in Contrast

While often criticized for the capitalist nature of their economies, Western nations like the United States, the UK, and the EU have successfully maintained multicultural frameworks. These countries have increasingly embraced diversity, fostering inclusive societies where multiple ethnicities, cultures, and religions can coexist. The West has faced its own challenges in integrating diverse populations; however, the principles of freedom and inclusion continue to drive debates around migration, civil rights, and social equity.

By contrast, China's state-driven economic nationalism and cultural repression severely limit the rights of minorities and challenge its global standing. While the West faces the challenge of reconciling capitalist priorities with human rights, it still functions under a framework of individual freedoms that contrast starkly with China's authoritarian governance model.

India: The Champion of Multiculturalism and Linguistic Diversity

One of the key distinctions of India lies in its commitment to multiculturalism. As a nation with a multitude of religions, languages, and ethnic groups, India represents an extraordinary example of cultural pluralism. India not only embraces its diversity but celebrates it through its constitutional guarantees of freedom of religion and recognition of multiple languages. The Indian Constitution ensures that citizens from different backgrounds can coexist peacefully, and the country’s strength lies in its ability to maintain social harmony amidst this diversity.

India’s linguistic and cultural pluralism is reflected in its everyday life, with over 2,000 languages spoken and a variety of religious practices observed by its citizens. This contrasts sharply with China's uniform approach to governance, which attempts to suppress non-Han Chinese cultures in favor of a singular national identity. India’s inclusive approach is not without its challenges, but it continues to stand as a testament to the belief that diversity can be a unifying force rather than a source of division.

Sri Lanka: The Strategic Pivot in the Indian Ocean

Amid the shifting dynamics of global power, Sri Lanka occupies a critical position in the Indian Ocean. Historically a strategic location for maritime routes, Sri Lanka is now at the center of geopolitical competition. China’s increasing influence in Sri Lanka, particularly through its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), has caused concern for India and the United States, which are wary of Beijing's growing footprint in the region.

The solution, however, might lie in Sri Lanka's division. As Sri Lanka faces mounting pressures, it may be compelled to consider a two-nation solution—Tamil Eelam and Sinhala Eelam—dividing the island along ethnic and political lines. The rationale behind this division lies in the strategic positioning of the two nations: Tamil Eelam, with its coastal advantages, could become a sea power, while Sinhala Eelam, with its landlocked positioning, could lose its significance in the Indian Ocean’s maritime security dynamics.

This division would dramatically alter Sri Lanka’s geopolitical role, and the international community, particularly the U.S. and India, may be forced to intervene in the form of humanitarian interventions or ICC cases, considering Sri Lanka’s historical issues with human rights. As the world shifts toward a more fragmented global order, Sri Lanka may find itself at the crossroads of competing geopolitical interests, with its future increasingly uncertain.

Conclusion: A New Multipolar World and the Role of the Indian Ocean

The Indian Ocean is emerging as the fulcrum of future global stability, where the interests of global powers intersect. China’s expansionism in the region, coupled with its internal contradictions, presents a challenge for the West and India. Yet, the resilience of democratic and multicultural societies, particularly in the West and India, provides an alternative model to China's authoritarianism. Meanwhile, Sri Lanka’s strategic location in the Indian Ocean will play a pivotal role in shaping the future of global power dynamics, potentially altering the balance between sea and land powers in the region.

As the world transitions toward a new order, Sri Lanka’s future will depend on its ability to navigate these geopolitical currents, balancing the interests of China, India, and the West. In the end, the key to a stable global order may not only lie in the assertion of power but also in strategic restraint, where diplomacy and cooperation shape the future, avoiding the pitfalls of unchecked aggression.

Nila Bala (Balananthini Balasubramaniam)

22:40

04/04/2025

United Kingdom

(Disclaimer: Images are AI generated and are used for representational purposes only)

***************************************************************